The week before trial, an assistant district attorney opens the lab's shared folder and downloads everything: the analyst's report, the case file, the photographs, the instrument printouts. Some files land in the Downloads folder, some in a synced folder, and the photos go onto a thumb drive for the courtroom. A paralegal gets a copy by email. All of it feels like ordinary trial prep, because it is.
Each of those downloads is a new copy that nobody is tracking. Good digital evidence management in a prosecutor's office starts with a plain question: once lab files leave the place they were shared, who knows where they went, which version they are, and what happens to them when the case closes? In many offices, nobody can answer that with confidence.
At a glance
- Every downloaded evidence file is a copy that sits outside the lab's controls and, often, outside your office's retention rules.
- Reviewing files in place, limiting downloads on unmanaged devices, and encrypting the laptops you manage removes most of the exposure without slowing attorneys down.
- Disclosure duties and records rules belong to counsel. IT's job is to make sure the office can say where every copy is.
How a convenient download turns into a disclosure question
Lab reports, case files, and supporting data reach your office through a portal, a shared site, or an emailed link. Once an attorney downloads them, control moves from the lab to whatever device the attorney happens to be using. The lab can still show what it released and when. It usually can't show what happened next, and your office often can't either.
That gap rarely matters on an ordinary day. It matters when someone asks a pointed question. Did the defense receive the same version the expert relied on? Where are the copies of the photographs now that the case has been dismissed? Who still holds files that left with an attorney who moved to private practice? If the honest answer is "we'd have to ask around," the office has a problem no single setting will fix.
Four ways the copies cause trouble
Lost or unmanaged devices. A laptop left in a car, a home computer used for a late night of trial prep, a phone that synced a folder of scene photos. If the device isn't encrypted and managed, the office may not be able to show the files were protected, or remove them.
Departing staff. Attorneys, investigators, and paralegals move to other offices, the defense bar, and private practice. Their accounts get disabled on the last day. Files they downloaded to a personal device or a USB drive stay where they are.
Version confusion. Labs issue amended and supplemental reports. If three people each keep a downloaded copy from a different week, nobody can be sure which one went to the defense, which one the witness reviewed, and which one sits in the trial binder. Fewer copies mean fewer of those questions at the worst possible moment.
Discovery and disclosure. Prosecutors carry disclosure obligations under constitutional rules, state discovery law, and court orders. What has to be disclosed, when, and how are legal questions for counsel. Scattered copies make those obligations harder to meet, and harder to prove you met.
Digital evidence management that keeps files in place
The simplest control is to keep files where they were shared and bring the attorney to them. Review happens in the browser or a managed app. Downloads happen by exception, for a reason someone can name, such as a courtroom exhibit or a production to the defense.
In Microsoft 365, that usually means SharePoint or Teams sites organized by case, with access granted to the people working that case and removed when they're done. Attorneys can read, comment on, and discuss files without creating a local copy. Large video files or phone extraction data may need a specialized viewer or a dedicated evidence platform, and the same principle holds: review the files where they live.
Keeping files in one place also gives the office one place to answer questions. When the lab amends a report, the new version lands in a single location. Version history shows what changed, and nobody has to search laptops for the old copy.
Limit downloads on devices you don't manage
Attorneys will open case files from home computers and personal tablets, especially close to trial. SharePoint and OneDrive let you decide what happens when they do. Microsoft's unmanaged device controls can block access from devices that aren't managed, or allow limited, web-only access. With limited access, people can view and preview files in the browser but can't download, print, or sync them.
You can apply these controls across the whole tenant or to specific sites, so case sites can be tightened without changing every other site in the office. They rely on Microsoft Entra Conditional Access, so confirm your licensing before you plan around them. Pilot with a small group first. The first time an attorney can't print an exhibit from home the night before trial, you'll want a documented exception path that works.
Make the laptops you manage earn their access
For office-issued laptops, Microsoft Intune compliance policies set the conditions a device has to meet, such as encryption, a supported operating system version, and an acceptable threat level. Devices that fall short are marked noncompliant, and Conditional Access can block them from case sites until they're fixed. On Windows, Intune can enforce BitLocker and back up recovery keys to Microsoft Entra ID.
Some downloads will still happen, and they should land on encrypted devices the office can track, lock, or wipe. Pair that with audit logging in Microsoft Purview, which can record file access and download events depending on licensing and configuration. Together, they let the office reconstruct who took which file, and when.
Plan for the end of the case
Downloaded copies outlive cases. A case closes, an appeal ends, or a record is sealed or expunged, and copies of the evidence sit on laptops and drives indefinitely. Retention schedules and sealing orders apply to the office's copies too, and they're hard to honor when nobody knows where the copies are.
When files stay in SharePoint, Microsoft Purview retention policies and labels can keep content for a defined period and then delete it. Retention labels can also route content to a disposition review, so a person approves the deletion first. If someone deletes retained content early, SharePoint keeps a copy in a hidden Preservation Hold library until the retention period ends. Which periods apply, and how sealing orders and legal holds interact with them, is a decision for counsel and your records officer. The configuration carries out that decision once it's made.
Where CJIS fits
Some of what moves between the lab and your office may be criminal justice information, or sit next to it in the case file. Where CJI is involved, the FBI's CJIS Security Policy sets requirements for access control, auditing, encryption, and the devices and media that store it. Your state's CJIS Systems Agency is usually the right place to confirm how the policy applies to your office.
There is no CJIS certification for a product or a vendor. Microsoft's documentation states that the FBI doesn't certify its compliance, and describes agreements Microsoft signs with state CJIS Systems Agencies for its U.S. Government cloud services, including Office 365 GCC. If CJI will live in your Microsoft 365 tenant, the tenant type, those agreements, and your own configuration all matter. A "CJIS compliant" label on a product answers none of those questions by itself.
Coordinate with the lab
The lab already decides how files leave its systems, so the most useful conversations happen before trial season, between your office IT, counsel, and the lab's quality and IT staff. Agree on how files are shared, whether access expires, how amended reports are announced, and which formats need a specialized viewer.
Keep each side's responsibilities clear. The lab's chain of custody and quality records cover the evidence and its release. Your office's controls cover what happens after receipt. When both sides document their part, nobody has to guess where one record ends and the next begins.
Start with one case
Pick one active case and trace every copy of the lab's files. Count the downloads, devices, email attachments, and drives. Then ask which of those copies the attorney needed. The list of copies the case required is usually short, and review in place can cover most of the rest.
At CTP, we help labs and their agency partners design evidence sharing with access scoped to a case and an end date built in. See how we approach forensic and crime laboratory IT, or read more about sharing crime lab evidence with partners.

